Blog

Practicing vs. Performing

Saturday, April 24th, 2010

“The way you practice it is the way you will perform it.”

These words echo in my head often, usually in my father’s voice. I’m not sure where he first heard it, or perhaps he was inspired and came up with it on his own. In any case, it has stuck with me through the years.

When I was very young, I think that practicing like a performance motivated me to think about the quality of tone, and intonation, that I produced. My first teacher, Lacy McLarry, would often advise me to “close your eyes and imagine that you are in Carnegie Hall”, which also gave me a sense of grand purpose and detailed focus. He is also largely responsible for my Heifetz obsession. :) But over the years, these admonitions have come to mean different things, often evolving as I reach different levels of cellistic understanding. (Also, after performing in Carnegie Hall last year, I now have a different, less fantastical but no less exciting view when I close my eyes.)

Practicing vs. Performing. Analytical vs. Free? There’s just something about being in front of an audience that tears down the walls, and I feel free. This feeling is hard to replicate in a small practice room, or on a hotel bed facing a mirror, my own familiar visage staring back and daring me to be vulnerable in front of my harshest critic. Is practicing the pursuit of perfection, and performing the art of transcendence?

No. This is where the struggle, and joy, of practicing lies for me right now. How can I play in the moment, every moment, even when I am “getting ready”, or “wood-shedding”? How to keep multiple lines of focus running at the same time: feel the phrase, experience and project the emotion, stay relaxed and strong, keep good hand position, make that shift, love the ring of that chord…? Visualization is key, and trust is essential. Practicing is all about building trust. Finding what is good and repeating it, helping it grow, not just berating yourself for mistakes and giving the foibles undeserved attention.

Bach today was better. Some moments really felt connected, not just like preparation, but a real musical and meaningful experience. The amazing and ironic thing is that when you can let go, even in practice, often those little bobbles disappear of their own accord (a concept explored in “The Inner Game of Tennis“) and you experience a unique and exhilarating energy that touches on what makes performing such a human phenomenon.

Every note counts. Each phrase can mean something. The cellist sitting alone in his room is also worthy of feeling moved by the music, even as it flows through him.

Practice it the way you will perform it.

Comments

  1. David  |  April 24th, 2010

    Well said, Joshua. I wonder how you sustain the hour upon hour of scales and arpeggios I’ve heard over the years? How important they are to the core of music, yet how difficult to find the motivation to do them. I wonder what a Carnegie Hall audience would do in response to twenty minutes of slow scales? :-)

  2. fernanda  |  April 24th, 2010

    great words, great post!

  3. Michael D. Malone  |  April 24th, 2010

    Dear Joshua,

    Read the above and I must admit, I am jealous. They say I am a good writter; but, I must say that that is beautifully written. I seriously doubt that I could match it; however, I know I have acertain talent which I draw apon as in the Wealth of Nations. I wanted to watch you perform in Albany, New York on April 23rd; but, due to another situation, I was unable to attend. I did buy you a little present just to thank you for your artistery and the beauty of your written prose. Perhaps, I will have another opportunity to approach you for an autograph. I really do not know music but I know what I enjoy like yourself and Joshua Bell.

    Best of LUCK. Thankyou for your entertainment.

  4. Mary Ann Allen  |  April 27th, 2010

    Oh my gosh, I had been thinking of “The Inner Game of Tennis” as I was reading the beginning of this entry, and then you mention it later on in here! It was published while I was in my undergrad years and every performance major was reading it and carrying it around like The Bible. Even some of us ED majors read it, just because we had to perform recitals too, and we weren’t as well prepared as the performance majors. How fasinating to realize that you performers work so hard in preperation. I know that there is preperation but until reading about it in your words, I often thought that you all have it “in your fingers” and its just a matter of get it up and ready for a gig. I am so glad to have read this and can now appreciate the live performances all the better. Thank you for your gift!

  5. Emily  |  April 28th, 2010

    How is it that I live a life absolutely immersed in cello and teaching and have only now discovered you? What a treasure. Love the blog, love your playing, love the poofy hair. I have much catching up to do!

    Em

  6. Emiko  |  April 29th, 2010

    Great post!!! :)

Leave a Comment